Hen Walsh's account of Stalingrad offers a strong alternative a military history Walsh may cover the same ground but his is a narrative of logistics and tactical planning an account of where troops moved and fought why plans were conceived and what they meant militarily There's a large overlap between Beevor and Walsh both include the same basic detail but Beevor's prose is personal while Walsh's text considers the limits of German national power and the nature of Vernichtungschlacht warfare Where Beevor discusses the difficulty of providing exact figures Walsh just gives them and where Beevor's writing is ceaselessly gripping Walsh is sedate educational and discursive In short these books are aimed at different audiences anyone who likes reading will enjoy Beevor but someone who wants the military specifics and contexts will benefit from Walsh
stalingrad pdf 1942 pdf 1943 free Stalingrad 1942 book Stalingrad 1942 1943 PDFEPUBHen Walsh's account of Stalingrad offers a strong alternative a military history Walsh may cover the same ground but his is a narrative of logistics and tactical planning an account of where troops moved and fought why plans were conceived and what they meant militarily There's a large overlap between Beevor and Walsh both include the same basic detail but Beevor's prose is personal while Walsh's text considers the limits of German national power and the nature of Vernichtungschlacht warfare Where Beevor discusses the difficulty of providing exact figures Walsh just gives them and where Beevor's writing is ceaselessly gripping Walsh is sedate educational and discursive In short these books are aimed at different audiences anyone who likes reading will enjoy Beevor but someone who wants the military specifics and contexts will benefit from Walsh